The moral theory emphasizes on the value of making considerations of the potential consequences of actions. The central principle of the ethical view is that actions taken should produce happiness and pleasure to a large number of people 59. Feb 06, 20 last semester, i was assigned to write a final paper on utilitarianism and kantian ethics for my philosophy class. Barbara mackinnon utilitarianism and kants moral theory. Dodds, lecture 2 kantian moral theory and utilitarianism are two theories that attempt to answer the ethical nature of human beings. Death penalty, which as well referred to as execution or capital punishment, is one amongst these variations which have caused several arguments and debates. Utilitarianism and the categorical imperative frame publishing. Twentiethcentury echoes of kant and hume 35 michael friedman kant and the problem of. Kantianism according to thiroux and krasemann 2012, utilitarianism is, a normative ethical theory originally established by jeremy bentham and john stuart mill that advocates brining about good consequences or happiness to all concerned pp. This essay will compare and contrast the philosophy of. Kantianism vs utilitarianism i would like to preface this by saying that i personally subscribe to the theory of utilitarianism when it comes to ethics, but ive been trying to broaden my horizons. Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory in that it is concerned with the consequences of the moral judgment, the outcome of the costbenefit analysis. Utilitarianism has its benefits but requires much more effort to do than kants ethics.
Compare and contrast kants duty ethics with utilitarianism. There is hardly any similarity between utilitarianism and kantianism. May 30, 2011 kant is ultimately veracity and to be aimed for as the idealism, and thus utilitarianism is an exception to the rule peace to you october 1, 2015 at 10. Utilitarianism and relativism research papers look at the similarities of these philosophy viewpoints. We are motivated to seek pleasure and minimize pain. These two philosophers examined the nature of morality a long time ago and they formed two different theories of. P1 if utilitarianism is true, the people in the cave should. But what moral philosophers are trying to find is a moral theory that is true, and if we judge what is true or not by how restrictive or unnecessarily tormenting it. Nonetheless, a careful reading of kant reveals that he did not adequately consider utilitarianism or other consequentialist normative theories. Kant and mill a comparison of ethical theories philosophy. This is the basic motivation for all actions, either directly or. May 31, 2014 while both mills consequentialist principle of utility and kants deontological categorical imperative seem both to have ethical import, the applicability of each depends on the situation to which they are applied.
I think this is partly because they are often not themes that kant himself explicitly emphasized. The mercy deathkilling debate euthanasia is the practice of ending a life in order to release an individual from unbearable suffering or an incurable disease. Yeah, kants system of ethics is often found to be very restrictive. Kantians believe human life is valuable because humans are the bearers of rational life oneill 414. Consequentialism, egoism, and the moral law bates college. Kantian deontology, act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism, are described and. Both kants ethics and utilitarianism greatly analogize between each other as kant is deontological which means that someone ought to do things because they are right, as it is duty and that in itself makes it right. Ethics can be defined as the conscious reflection on our moral beliefs with the aim of improving, extending or refining those beliefs in some way. Utilitarianism, kantian ethics, natural rights theories. Since he is a deontologist he presumes that there is a universal moral imperative, certain ways in which we must act, no matter what our individual desires or needs or utility might be. A consequentialist normative theory is any theory which asserts that the fundamental normative principle directs us to bring about good ends. The centerpiece of kants deontological sensibility is the prioritization of duties over consequences. However, these two philosophies take on different standpoints on ethics. If kant is correct, then it would seem that utilitarianism, and any other consequentialist normative principle, is misguided.
John mills utilitarianism and immanuel kants fundamental principle of the metaphysic of morality present the two philosophers divergent views on the field of moral philosophy. But both hold equally that morality must be deduced from principles. We can admit that the increase in the happiness to others is a good reason to execute joseph. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Oct 26, 2014 both kant and mill would agree that goodness comes from hitting that subscribe button. In this paper, the issues towards pros and cons of both theories will not be addressed as. Utilitarianism focuses on the effects of an action. Kant states that a we believe that an act performed with good intentions has moral worth, and we admire the agent, even when no good results 1785. Kants ethical theory revolves around the idea of the. Kants critique of utilitarianism is that it treats people as a means not as an ends in themselves. Im supposed to explore the topic from the perspectives of the act utilitarian, the rule utilitarian, and someone who follows a deontological train of thought.
Utilitarianism tells us that it is the happiness or well being of sentient beings that is the valuable thing. Start studying utilitarianism and kant s moral theory phil 101. In this chapter, we survey a set of results in socialchoice theory that provides an axiomatic basis for generalized utilitarianism and, in some cases, utilitarianism itself. Kant presents three related considerations to support his complex conclusion. A field opens up for the practice of virtue, one that is governed neither by pure altruism nor by pure egoism, for both of those extremes are logically untenable. Kantianism ethics can be defined as the conscious reflection on our moral beliefs with the aim of improving, extending or refining those beliefs in some way. Pdf kantian and utilitarian ethics on capital punishment. Utilitarianism says that an act is justified if maximum numbers of people are deriving happiness out of it. Both kant and mill would agree that goodness comes from hitting that subscribe button.
Immanuel kant was born in 1724 and was a renowned german philosopher with huge influences on modern philosophy. Traces of utilitarian thought can be found in the works of plato and aristotle, but not until the eighteenth century did utilitarianism truly begin to emerge as a welldefined and. Utilitarianism7 as well as truth and falsehood, are questions of observation and experience. The ethics of assisted reproduction technologies introduction assisted reproduction has become more widely used in recent years. Oct 19, 2014 kantianism and utilitarianism have different ways for determining whether an act we do is right or wrong. Utilitarianism but which states of affairs are valuable and which states of affairs are not. Kantianism vs utilitarianism attitude towards what is right or wrong is what constitutes the basic difference between utilitarianism and kantianism. Jan 06, 20 kantianism vs utilitarianism attitude towards what is right or wrong is what constitutes the basic difference between utilitarianism and kantianism. Kants moral theory is summed up by the term categorical imperative in that it makes demands that do not depend on context or consequences. Im supposed to write a paper talking about whether or not individuals have a moral duty to reduce our carbon footprint. Utilitarianism and kants moral theory phil 101 flashcards. Kant and utilitarianism kant and utilitarianism research papers look at a sample of an order placed for a comparison between two philosophical approaches. I had to study and evaluate the work of two philosophers named jeremy bentham and immanuel kant. Difference between kantianism and utilitarianism compare.
The important point is that one neednt believe that utilitarianism is the correct moral theory in order to believe that consequentist arguments of either the strictly utilitarian kind or other kinds provide good reasons. Kant or utilitarianism essay example for free newyorkessays database with more than 65000 college essays for studying. Utilitarianism 7 as well as truth and falsehood, are questions of observation and experience. Kantianism and utilitarianism have different ways for determining whether an act we do is right or wrong. Some of the individuals feel so strongly about being right they will argue until they get their. If we exclude the utility calculations of people not directly related to the case, its pretty simple. Act utilitarianism is right only if the result of good is just as much or more than any other available substitute. Kant is ultimately veracity and to be aimed for as the idealism, and thus utilitarianism is an exception to the rule peace to you october 1, 2015 at 10. Personal integrity p1 if utilitarianism is true, then jim is morally obligated to kill the one native himself. Kant stated that a universal law should provide the basis for each act, and that the intention was of more importance than the result. Mills utilitarianism is a more refined ethical theory compared to kants breakdown of the metaphysics and its use in proving what is right and what is wrong. Neff 1 introduction have you ever watched a group debate an ethical decision given a particular case study with several different variations to the story. Unfortunately i am not currently enrolled in a philosophy course, nor have i been enrolled in one previously, although i do have a passing interest. Kant revolutionized our thinking about what it is to have a mind.
Compare and contrast kantianism and utilitarianism term. Both utilitarianism and kantian deontology seem to offer us the ideal solution. Utilitarianism as human beings it is inevitable that we make decisions everyday, whether it be as simple as holding a door open for a stranger or as heroic as pulling someone out of a burning car. Kant believed that good will was the only thing truly good that could be used to determine a persons morality. As we have discussed in previous essays, kant believed that moral rules could be known through reason and not just by observation shaw and barry 69. Can utilitarianism account for justice and fairness. Those who are not students of philosophy, words like utilitarianism and kantianism may sound alien, but for those who try to tackle questions of ethics and wisdom, these two represent important viewpoints. Rule utilitariankantian views of a cannibalism case i am doing a paper on the cannibalism case of armin meiwes germany 2001. Start studying utilitarianism and kants moral theory phil 101. Deontology vs utilitarianism the theory of deontology is derived from the writings of german philosopher immanuel kant 17241804. The justification for the theory is simple, human beings feel pleasure and pain. Kant s arguments focus on questions of moral motiva.
Consider the following situation for kant and utilitarianism research paper. Both kantianism and utilitarianism are ethical theories that express the ethical standard of an action. Kantian ethics and utilitarianism chapter 12 the cambridge. Contents kantian lessons about mind, meaning, and rationality 1 robert brandom meaning and aesthetic judgment in kant 21 eli friedlander carnap and quine. For one thing, the criterion dispute includes a dispute about whether there is any such moral instinct.
Richard hare argues that the fundamental assumptions of kant s ethical system should have led kant to utilitarianism, had kant not confused a norms generality with its universality, and hence. He was perhaps most known for his work critique of practical reason which looked at the way we as humans use reason to arrive at result. Utilitarianism takes no account of integrity the accidental act or one done with evil intent if promoting good ends is the good act. According to kant, we should look at our maxims, or intentions, of the particular action. A police search of their cold case files revealed the case of john henkel shot and killed. Two facts about the emergence of kantian and utilitarian ethics. In all of these fields, utilitarianism has its proponents and utilitarian arguments are common. I need to determine how an act and rule utilitarian would view this case. The moral action is that which produces the greatest good for the greatest number. What are the similarities and differences between kants. View essay this essay will compare and contrast the philosophy of utilitarianism verses kant from marketing 3201 at columbia southern university. In this essay we will discuss what kants and a utilitarians view on insider trading would be.
Rule utilitarianism is a branch of the broader utilitarian. Bentham believed that we should only factor the quantity of pleasure, or to what extent it provides pleasure in the greatest amount to the greatest number of people. Compare and contrast kantianism and utilitarianism term paper. Career oriented women, gay and lesbian couples, single mothers. What is the difference between kantianism and utilitarianism. Being assigned to compare and contrast kants duty ethics with utilitarianism, it should be emphasized that these theories are two of five known studies about ethics approach. Jul 16, 2016 kants critique of utilitarianism is that it treats people as a means not as an ends in themselves. He tendency to a disjunctive classification of systems is so strong that to many the subj ect of this paper may seem an impossible one. While both mills consequentialist principle of utility and kants deontological categorical imperative seem both to have ethical import, the applicability of each depends on the situation to which they are applied. Last semester, i was assigned to write a final paper on utilitarianism and kantian ethics for my philosophy class. Kant and mill represent to us such poles of ethical thought, that the discovery of any common ground between them which might form the basis of a relation, may appear a. Deontology is a dutybased ethical position, where ones actions are based on what is ethically correct, regardless of the. Utilitarianism states that what makes an action right is that it produces the greatest amount of happiness not just your happiness, but others as well.
Some of what seem to me to be among the most important lessons he taught us are often not yet sufficiently appreciated, however. To answer it with confidence would require more concentrated study of kants text than i have yet had time for. Kant and utilitarianism research papers compare two. Both kants ethics and utilitarianism greatly analogize between each other as kant is deontological which means that someone ought to do things because they are right, as it is duty and that in itself. Utilitarianism is that the goodness or rightness of an ethic in question, depends on the desirability of its consequences. Mill, kant, and capital punishment research papers delve into mills utilitarian view of morality versus kants perception of the categorical imperative view. That would be a form of consequentialism, which he is. Kantianism is another famous rule of the nonconsequentialist theory. A full statement of kants legal and ethical theory, the metaphysics of morals, was to follow in 1797. This good will would make people act out of a sense of duty and not for example, out of self.
Utilitarianism says that an act is justified if maximum numbers of people are deriving happiness out of. There are many similarities between utilitarianism and kantianism that confuse some people. Utilitarianism and other kinds of academic papers in our essays database at many essays. P2 jim is not morally obligated to kill the one native himself. Kant on euthanasia essay 1875 words 8 pages philosophy 1610 22 april 20 euthanasia or just plain murder. Kants ethics vs utilitarianism essay example graduateway. Utilitarianism and the categorical imperative frame. He doesnt ever say not to do what you wouldnt want others to also do.
615 1237 874 230 944 444 904 769 1028 895 1323 675 1426 25 88 354 631 1318 405 715 240 1107 302 121 1379 605 23 1386 861 1263 873 1231 531 684 62 330 1203 1187